27 Comments

Love love love Pickwick Papers. Love Sam Seller’s character! Mr. Pickwick in jail, getting caught in a lady’s bedroom, Mr. Sondhrass’ escapades, Christmas in the countryside...just reminds me of winter vacation, snow, quintessential London and it’s countryside...maybe because I read/watched it during that season. Thanks for the roundup and the reminder of what a great writer Dickens is!

Expand full comment
author

Wonderful that we share an appreciation of Dickens, especially The Pickwick Papers, Anu.

Expand full comment
Apr 10, 2023Liked by Mike Goodenow Weber

Ahem. I've read "Tale of Two Cities" which is far down on your list I see, shall make a point to become more familiar with you top choices :)

Expand full comment
author

Hope you find some of them of high value, Troy.

Expand full comment

I have only read A Tale of Two Cities. I need to check out your top picks. I'm curious about Our Mutual Friend. I'll add it and maybe Pickwick to my reading list.

Expand full comment
author

Hope you find both meaningful, Roque. I just finished watching the 6-hour BBC miniseries of Our Mutual Friend. One of the most profound things I've ever watched.

Expand full comment

Wonderful article. Especially as it highlights how Dickens is not just a name associated with dusty books, but a source of immense relevance and importance for life itself. A worldview "we" here at Timeless wholeheartedly condone. :D Also helpful to me, as I'm planning an intensive catch-up-with-Dickens reading session at some point this year. (As I said before: the British are my weak spot in literature) I think I'll start with Hard Times. (since I have a copy already) That way, if it really is the weaker one - and I'll take your word for it - I can still enjoy it. If it isn't top-notch Dickens, it must still be worth the time, right? After all, most minor authors would be content with writing a novel at the level of a minor work of a great master. Dumas fils, to my knowledge, was content with La Dame aux Camelias when his father had several great works under his belt. (Of course their relationship was also complicated)

My one experience with Dickens - A Christmas Carol - remains unforgettable to this day, even after accounting for all the now-cliched Scrooge references in the greater Anglo culture. (Though I approve of Scrooge McDuck) Even our desire to "take care of the surplus population" still manifests itself in the world today, albeit with much greater "discretion" than Scrooge cares to utilize.

Expand full comment
author

Very interesting, Felix. Ah, Dumas. Read Musketeers three or four times when I was young. And the Count is a great novel and a great film.

Good point about Hard Times, and you might not end up agreeing with me that it's his weakest novel. Glad you feel I captured Dickens's immense relevance for life in our times.

Expand full comment
Sep 1, 2023Liked by Mike Goodenow Weber

I love A Christmas Carol...its writing draws you in from the first sentence and is so much more than the cloying sentimentality of the screen versions...thanks for your list, I am now going straight to the Pickwick Papers without passing go

Expand full comment
author

Very cool, Simon.

Expand full comment
May 25, 2023Liked by Mike Goodenow Weber

Yes to your assessment of Bleak House. It's a long book, and explores injustice on several societal levels, in a way only Dickens could. Characters often feel as though they are enduring life beyond their capacity, and then endure it some more.

Expand full comment
author

Excellent observation, Russell.

Expand full comment
May 9, 2023Liked by Mike Goodenow Weber

Just starting The Pickwick Papers.

Expand full comment
author

Awesome, Robert.

Expand full comment

You might be adding some gravitas to my reading list!

Expand full comment
author

Oh, he's plenty of fun too, Anna. Sometimes he's a barrel of monkeys.

Do you have more than one Substack? Am I subscribing to both of them or just one?

Expand full comment

I wrote a thesis on "Dombey and Son" back in the day, highly underrated and was (unjustly) hated by most students during my term as I recall. Not an easy read.

Expand full comment
author

Interesting. It's not a fun read, but meaningful, I thought.

Expand full comment

Very interesting, esp. read in the context of its time, which makes it less fun to read and more research for sure.

Small anecdote: Dickens was considered a rather basic writer in his time and was criticised much like Stephen King is today to the extent that there are articles that call him the Dickens of the 21st century...

Expand full comment
author

I can see that. He didn't hang out with George Eliot and her crowd, either. The intellectuals and the aristocrats both kinda looked down on Dickens. He didn't much care.

Expand full comment

Love these posts. Adding Pickwick Papers to my TBR list for this year. thanks!

Expand full comment
author

Very cool, Bill. Lemme know what you think.

Expand full comment

Wonderful, thoughtful examination of the great author. His voice and ideas echo down through the generations, without a doubt. One can't think of a writer such as, say, Steinbeck, without thinking of Dickens before him. Dickens had a big influence on Dostoevsky, who was born 16 years after Dickens. I remember well reading Dickens at my college-prep high school in Ojai (Southern Ca) in the late 90s. I hate to admit this but: I have read very little of the man since then. I've tried a few times and, for some reason, I just can't get through his work. I read a LOT of 19th century authors, and many lengthy tomes, so that's not the issue. I can't put my finger on it. But I should read him again, that's my point.

Have you read either Orwell's or Christopher Hitchens's astute, witty, largely fair but definitely acerbic takes on Dickens?

https://www.vanityfair.com/culture/2012/02/hitchens-201202

https://orwell.ru/library/reviews/dickens/english/e_chd

Anyway. Fun read, Mike.

Michael Mohr

"Sincere American Writing"

https://michaelmohr.substack.com/

Expand full comment
author

Thank you, Michael. I knew a woman named Mona from Ojai back in the late 1980s and early 1990s. She ran an art school there and wrote some art books. Mona Brooks. Her book Drawing with Children was a bestseller, I think, or close to it.

Thanks for the recommendations and links to Orwell and Hitchens.

For two decades I found Dickens depressing, so it's only the past few years I've gotten into him.

You might want to try some of the BBC miniseries. They've done almost every novel as a miniseries. Our Mutual Friend is one of the most profound film performances I've ever seen, and I think you'd appreciate it. A six-hour miniseries.

Expand full comment
author

Mona Brookes, maybe, with an "e"

Expand full comment

Have you ever visited the Dickens House in London? If so, would you recommend it?

Expand full comment
author

Never been to London.

Expand full comment